Whiffing on Wifery: The Redefinition of “Spiritual Wives” and its Distortion of Church History

Abstract

This paper critically examines the historical narrative surrounding the term "spiritual wifery" and its association with John C. Bennett's activities in Nauvoo. The commonly accepted definition of "spiritual wifery" as illicit sexual relations kept secret is scrutinized and found to lack historical support. By analyzing primary sources, including Bennett's letters and his book The History of the Saints, this study reveals that the term "spiritual wifery" has been misapplied and misunderstood. The paper argues that Bennett's definition of "spiritual wifery" was more complex and structured, involving secret ceremonies and a hierarchical system. This misapplication has distorted the historical understanding of Mormon polygamy and Joseph Smith's teachings. The article remains neutral regarding the veracity of claims made by historical figures on any side. The sole motive is to ascertain the correct definition of the "spiritual wife doctrine" as it relates to Mormon history. The paper calls for a reevaluation of the term "spiritual wifery" to gain a more accurate understanding of Latter-day Saint history.